South Africa

Death Penalty 100/100

1 Does the country retain the death penalty for drug offences? No

source: Harm Reduction International (2021), THE DEATH PENALTY FOR DRUG OFFENCES: GLOBAL OVERVIEW, Available online at: https://www.hri.global/death-penalty-2020

South Africais not listed as one of the states that retains the death penalty for drug offences in Harm Reduction International's (2021) The Death Penalty for Drug Offences: Global Overview 2020.

2 What is the extent of death penalty application for drug offences in the country? N/A

source: Harm Reduction International (2021), THE DEATH PENALTY FOR DRUG OFFENCES: GLOBAL OVERVIEW, Available online at: https://www.hri.global/death-penalty-2020

Not Applicable

Extra-Judicial Killing 75/100

3 To what extent is the practice of extra-judicial killing prevalent in the course of military and police anti-drug activity? To a small extent

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

Militarised Policing 50/100

4 To what extent are military or special security forces are involved in drug operations? To a moderate extent

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

Life Sentencing 100/100

5 Is there provision in legislation or sentencing frameworks for the imposition of life imprisonment for drug offences? No

source: GDPI Coding Team.

The South African Drugs and Drug Trafficking Act 1992 states that the maximum sentence for crimes should not exceed 25 years. This was underscored by the Section 51 of the Criminal Law (Sentencing) Amendment Act, 2007.

6 Where there is provision in legislation or sentencing frameworks for the imposition of life imprisonment for drug offences, what is the nature of such sentences? N/A

source: GDPI Coding Team.

Not Applicable

7 How frequently are formal life sentences imposed for drug use and personal possession offences? N/A

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

Not Applicable

8 How frequently are formal life sentences imposed for drug supply offences (production, dealing, or trafficking)?  N/A

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

Not Applicable

Non-consensual confinement 75/100

9 To what extent is there a practice of non-consensual confinement in compulsory drug treatment centres? To a small extent

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

Human Rights Violations 32/100

1 How often are suspects in drug cases subject to violence or torture by the police? Frequently

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

2 To what extent does arbitrary arrest and detention for drug offences exist? To a very large extent

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

3 What is the country's score on the World Bank Fair Trial Indicator? Moderately Restricted

source: World Bank Data Repository: https://tcdata360.worldbank.org/indicators/hd45eb4d6?country=BRA&indicator=41895&viz=line_chart&years=1975,2019

The courts are generally independent of the government, but the justice system is characterized by moderate degrees of corruption or inefficiency.

Equity of Impact of Criminal Justice Response 8/100

4 To what extent does enforcement of drug policy disproportionately impact certain ethnic groups?  To a very large extent

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

5 To what extent does enforcement of drug policy disproportionately impact women?  To a large extent

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

6 To what extent does enforcement of drug policy disproportionately impact low-income groups? To a very large extent

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

Mandatory minumum sentencing and pre-trial detention 100/100

7 Do the state’s drug laws or legal frameworks include mandatory minimum sentences for any drug offences? No

source: GDPI Coding Team.

Criminal Law (Sentencing) Ammendment Act 2007. Section 51. Changes the 'minimum sentences' used for crimes such as large scale drug trafficking to 'discretionary minimum sentences'.

8 For states whose drug laws or legal frameworks include mandatory minimum sentences for any drug offences, does this relate to first offences or multiple offences? N/A

source: GDPI Coding Team.

Not Applicable

9 Do the state’s laws include mandatory pre-trial detention for drug offences? No

source: GDPI Coding Team.

Drugs and Drug Trafficking Act 1992. Section 12, subsections 1 to 3. Anyone suspected of withholding information with regards to a drug offence can be detained IF the magistrate deems it necessary and issues a warrant. They shall be detained until the magistrate orders their release. Not mandatory.

Alternatives to arrest/prosecution/conviction/punishment 44/100

10 Is there any provision in state criminal justice policy for alternatives to arrest, prosecution, conviction and/or punishment for drug-related offences? Yes

source: GDPI Coding Team.

Prevention of and Treatment for Substance Abuse Act 2008- Section 36. A court that convicts a person of any offence can order that the offender is referred to a treatment centre. This can occur “in lieu of any sentence”. This can only occur if the person is deemed to be a danger to themselves/others on account of their dependency or commits a criminal act to sustain their dependency.

11 Do alternatives exist at the point of initial contact with law enforcement (i.e., the police or other law enforcement officers) – before arrest and/or prosecution? No

source: GDPI Coding Team.

No provision for this in Prevention and Prevention of Substance Abuse Act 2008. Discussed with MJ Stowe who has said he is not aware of provision for this in national legislation.

12 Do alternatives exist after the point of arrest, but before conviction or formal criminal court proceedings? No

source: GDPI Coding Team.

No provision for such alternatives is present in Prevention of and Treatment for Substance Abuse Act 2008.

13 Where individuals are convicted with a final sentence (courts), are there alternatives to incarceration for drug offences? Yes

source: GDPI Coding Team.

Diversion only occurs after a final sentence is passed by judge. That is, it occurs in lieu of a sentence.

14 Do alternatives to arrest, prosecution, conviction and/or punishment for drug-related offences include treatment or care elements?  Yes

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This was ascertained through the GDPI survey of survey of experts in state drug policy.

15 Where alternatives to arrest, prosecution, conviction and/or punishment for drug-related offences include treatment or care elements, is relapse / non-attendance / treatment “failure” associated with subsequent imprisonment or punishment? Yes

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This was ascertained through the GDPI survey of survey of experts in state drug policy.

16 Where alternatives to arrest, prosecution, conviction and/or punishment for drug-related offences include treatment or care elements, are a range of treatment options and modalities made available to people based on their clinically assessed need or preferences? No

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This was ascertained through the GDPI survey of survey of experts in state drug policy.

Extent of imprisonment of individuals involved in non-violent drug-related offences 0

17 To what extent does the pursuit of state drug policy result in the imprisonment of non-violent offenders? To a very large extent

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (adjusted for topic confidence levels) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

Decriminalisation Policy 57/100

18 Is there a provision in national legislation or in official national policy documents for the decriminalisation of drug use and the possession of drugs for personal use?  Yes

source: GDPI Coding Team.

South Africa’s model of decriminalisation was introduced with the South African Constitutional Court decision in Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development and Others v Prince; National Director of Public Prosecutions and Others v Rubin; National Director of Public Prosecutions and Others v Acton and Others [2018] ZACC 30 in 2018. Personal and private use of cannabis is decriminalised. So is manufacture for personal use. This ruling makes amendments to Drugs and Drug Trafficking Act with regards to cannabis consumption and production for personal use. Brought into place to respect religious freedoms of rastafarian population.

19 What % of the population live in a state/territory with decriminalisation provisions? 100%

source: GDPI Coding Team.

This law applies nationwide.

20 For states or sub-national units with decriminalisation, what substances are decriminalised? Cannabis Only

source: GDPI Coding Team.

Constitutional Court of South Africa Case CCT 108/17, September 2018. Under ‘Judgement’, section 17. Rules that the relevant sections of the Drugs and Drug Trafficking Act relating to possession and manufacture of dependence-producing substances are inconsistent with the constitution ONLY with regards to cannabis for personal private use. Otherwise sections 4(b) and 5(b) of Drugs Act (laws prohibiting possession and dealing/manufacture of illicit substances) are still valid.

21 Where there are administrative (non-criminal) sanctions for drug use and possession for personal use, what is the severity of these sanctions? Moderate

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

22 To what extent has decriminalisation in this state been effective in diverting people who use drugs away from the criminal justice system? Not at all

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

Extent to which State Policy Prioritises Harm Reduction for People Who Use Drugs 87/100

1 Is there an explicit supportive reference to harm reduction in national policy documents? Yes

source: Harm Reduction International (2021), The Global State of Harm Reduction 2020 - 7th Edition. Available at: https://www.hri.global/global-state-of-harm-reduction-2020

Source: Harm Reduction International (2021), The Global State of Harm Reduction 2020 - 7th Edition. Available at: https://www.hri.global/global-state-of-harm-reduction-2028

2 Are people who use drugs included in the HIV national strategic plan? Yes

source: GDPI Coding Team.

National Plan for HIV, TB and STIs. Page 23, PWUD listed as 'key population'.

3 In states where people who use drugs are included in the HIV national strategic plan, are people who use drugs specified as key and vulnerable populations to be targeted for services? Yes

source: GDPI Coding Team.

Page 23 of National Strategic Plan for HIV, TB and STIs, PWUD listed as key population for HIV to be targeted. Page 66, table 11 lists preventative interventions but all they offer is drug screening and referral to treatment centres.

4 Are people who use drugs included in the Hepatitis-C national strategic plan? Yes

source: GDPI Coding Team.

National Strategic Plan HIV, TB, STIs. Page 29.

5 In states where people who use drugs are included in the Hepatitis-C national strategic plan, are people who use drugs specified as key and vulnerable populations to be targeted for services? Yes

source: GDPI Coding Team.

National Strategic Plan HIV, TB, STIs. Page 67. Under table listing intervention for Key HIV populations, an intervention for PWUD is Hepatitis C screening and immunisation services.

6 Are people who use drugs included in the Tuberculosis national strategic plan? Yes

source: GDPI Coding Team.

National Strategic Plan for HIV, TB and STIs. Page 29. States that drug use will increase risk of contracting TB.

7 In states where people who use drugs are included in the Tuberculosis national strategic plan, are people who use drugs specified as key and vulnerable populations to be targeted for services? No

source: GDPI Coding Team.

National Strategic Plan for HIV, TB and STIs page 23. PWUD not listed as key/vulnerable population for TB. BUT Page 29- Under section on harm reduction, it says that harmful drug use increases risk of TB and that harm reduction services to prevent young PWUD from getting TB will be expanded.

Harm Reduction Funding 11/100

8 How Adequate Are Levels of Harm Reduction Funding Relative to Estimated Need? Low

source: Harm Reduction International GDPI team

Estimated by Harm Reduction International at between 10-29% of harm reduction resource needs met (see project methodology for details)

9 Which of the following best describes the sustainability of harm reduction funding in the state over the next 3-5 years? Uncertain

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

Harm Reduction Intervention Availability and Coverage 27/100

10 Is at least one needle and syringe programme operational in the state? Yes

source: Harm Reduction International (2021), The Global State of Harm Reduction 2020 - 7th Edition. Available at: https://www.hri.global/global-state-of-harm-reduction-2020

Source: Harm Reduction International (2021), The Global State of Harm Reduction 2020 - 7th Edition. Available at: https://www.hri.global/global-state-of-harm-reduction-2028

11 Which of the following best describes the availability of needle and syringe programmes for people who inject drugs? Limited availability

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

12 Is at least one opioid agonist therapy programme operational in the state? Yes

source: Harm Reduction International (2021), The Global State of Harm Reduction 2020 - 7th Edition. Available at: https://www.hri.global/global-state-of-harm-reduction-2020

Source: Harm Reduction International (2021), The Global State of Harm Reduction 2020 - 7th Edition. Available at: https://www.hri.global/global-state-of-harm-reduction-2028

13 Which of the following best describes the availability of opioid agonist therapy programmes for people who use opioid drugs? Very limited availability

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

14 Is peer distribution of naloxone available in this state? No

source: Harm Reduction International (2021), The Global State of Harm Reduction 2020 - 7th Edition. Available at: https://www.hri.global/global-state-of-harm-reduction-2020

Source: Harm Reduction International (2021), The Global State of Harm Reduction 2020 - 7th Edition. Available at: https://www.hri.global/global-state-of-harm-reduction-2028

15 Which of the following best describes the availability of naloxone for people who use opioid drugs? Very Limited Availability

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

16 Is at least one in-prison needle and syringe programme operational in the state? No

source: Harm Reduction International (2021), The Global State of Harm Reduction 2020 - 7th Edition. Available at: https://www.hri.global/global-state-of-harm-reduction-2020

Source: Harm Reduction International (2021), The Global State of Harm Reduction 2020 - 7th Edition. Available at: https://www.hri.global/global-state-of-harm-reduction-2028

17 Which of the following best describes the availability of needle and syringe programmes to people in prison? Unavailable

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

18 Is at least one in-prison opioid agonist therapy programme operational in the state? No

source: Harm Reduction International (2021), The Global State of Harm Reduction 2020 - 7th Edition. Available at: https://www.hri.global/global-state-of-harm-reduction-2020

Source: Harm Reduction International (2021), The Global State of Harm Reduction 2020 - 7th Edition. Available at: https://www.hri.global/global-state-of-harm-reduction-2028

19 Which of the following best describes the availability of opioid agonist therapy to people in prison? Unavailable

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

20 Is at least one drug consumption room operational in ths state? No

source: Harm Reduction International (2021), The Global State of Harm Reduction 2020 - 7th Edition. Available at: https://www.hri.global/global-state-of-harm-reduction-2020

Source: Harm Reduction International (2021), The Global State of Harm Reduction 2020 - 7th Edition. Available at: https://www.hri.global/global-state-of-harm-reduction-2028

21 Which of the following best describes the availability of drug checking services to people who use drugs? Very Limited Availability

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

Equity of Access to Harm Reduction Services 32/100

22 To what extent are there disparities in access to harm reduction services due to individuals’ ethnicity? To a moderate extent

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

23 To what extent are there disparities in access to harm reduction services for women, including during pregnancy? To a large extent

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

24 To what extent are there disparities in access to harm reduction services due to individuals’ sexual orientation and/or gender identity?  To a large extent

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

Policy prioritisation of availability and accessibility of controlled medicines for the relief of pain and suffering 42/100

1 Is there an explicit provision in national legislation (or in official national policy documents and regulatory instruments) that establishes the government’s obligation to make adequate provision to ensure the availability of controlled medicines for the relief of pain and suffering? Yes

source: GDPI Coding Team.

National Drugs Master Plan page 47. Directly commits to reviewing Standard Treatment Guidelines and Essential Medicine List to ensure access to controlled substanced for purposes of alleviating suffering.

2 Is there an approved national medicines policy plan that recognises the importance of the availability and accessibility of controlled medicines for the relief of pain and suffering? No

source: GDPI Coding Team.

No medicines plan found

3 To what extent does the policy-making process relating to controlled medicines meaningfully include stakeholders such as medical boards, health professionals (including pharmacists), patients, and representatives of patients?  To a small extent

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

De facto availability and accessibility of controlled medicines for the relief of pain and suffering 12/100

4 What range of narcotic drug consumption does the state fall into? Low Access

source: INTERNATIONAL NARCOTICS CONTROL BOARD (2021) 2020 Narcotic Drugs Report. Available at: https://www.incb.org/incb/en/publications/annual-reports/annual-report-2020.html

Source: INTERNATIONAL NARCOTICS CONTROL BOARD (2021) 2020 Narcotic Drugs Report. Available at: https://www.incb.org/incb/en/publications/annual-reports/annual-report-2020.html

5 To what extent are there geographic disparities in access to controlled drugs for the treatment of pain? To a large extent

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

Equity of Access to controlled medicines for the relief of pain and suffering 44/100

6 To what extent are there disparities in access to controlled drugs for the treatment of pain due to individuals’ gender? To a small extent

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

7 To what extent are there disparities in access to controlled drugs for the treatment of pain due to individuals’ socio-economic status? To a large extent

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

8 To what extent are there disparities in access to controlled drugs for the treatment of pain due to individuals’ ethnicity? To a moderate extent

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

9 To what extent are there disparities in access to opioid analgesics for the treatment of pain for people who use drugs? To a large extent

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

This score reflects the median result (weighted by topic confidence level) of the GDPI survey of experts in state drug policy.

Filter Question for 'Development' Dimension N/A

1 Does the country include ‘alternative development’ or ‘sustainable development’ programmes to provide alternatives to the cultivation of crops used for illegal drug production? No

source: GDPI Coding Team.

No reference to sustainable/alternative development approaches to crop cultivation in legislation. This was confirmed by the GDPI expert survey.

Alternative Development Policy Design N/A

2 Are Alternative Development policies and programmes embedded within a broader development programme? N/A

source: GDPI Coding Team.

Not Applicable

3 To what extent are local communities, participants, and (where applicable) indigenous and minority groups meaningfully included in the design, implementation, monitoring, and evaluation of alternative development policies and programmes? N/A

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

Not Applicable

4 To what extent is the protection of the environment prioritised in alternative development policy and programmes?   N/A

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

Not Applicable

5 To what extent does alternative development operate within a framework of militarized/security sector operations as part of security policy? N/A

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

Not Applicable

Management of Crop Eradication N/A

6 Does alternative development policy include provisions for forced crop eradication? N/A

source: GDPI Coding Team.

Not Applicable

7 Where provision is made for forced crop eradication, does policy also make provision for aerial spraying in forced crop eradication? N/A

source: GDPI Coding Team.

Not Applicable

8 To what extent are alternative development programmes sequenced to ensure that targeted households have adopted viable and sustainable livelihoods in advance of any crop eradication efforts? N/A

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

Not Applicable

Efficacy of alternative development policy for key beneficiaries N/A

9 To what extent do alternative development policies and programmes facilitate the empowerment of women? N/A

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

Not Applicable

10 To what extent do alternative development policies and programmes benefit young people? N/A

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

Not Applicable

11 To what extent do alternative development policies and programmes implement a successful ‘pro-poor’ strategy? N/A

source: Survey of Experts in States' Drug Policy

Not Applicable